Okay, folks, let’s dive into my little adventure in MLB The Show 24, specifically, how I finally got myself traded. It wasn’t as straightforward as I thought, so I figured I’d share my stumbling blocks and what finally worked.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3df8d/3df8d0cc203f179ff153ae7ce0b7581544fbb500" alt="MLB The Show 24: Your Ultimate Guide on How to Get Traded Fast"
First off, I started a Road to the Show career. You know, the usual, created my player, got drafted… I was pumped, ready to climb the ranks. But then, I got stuck. Like, really stuck. My team wasn’t bad, but I just wasn’t feeling it. I wanted a change of scenery, a new challenge.
So, naturally, I figured, “I’ll just request a trade!” Easy, right? Wrong. I went into the menus, poked around, and… nothing. No obvious “Request Trade” button. I started to get a little frustrated.
My First Attempts (And Failures)
- I tried talking to my agent. Nope. Just the usual fluff about contracts and endorsements.
- I looked through the player options. Nada. Zilch.
- I even considered intentionally playing poorly, hoping they’d get fed up and trade me. But I’m too competitive for that, plus, it felt…wrong.
Then, I remembered something I’d read online – you gotta actually progress the story a bit. It’s not just about hitting dingers; you need to interact, build relationships, and make some noise.
What Actually Worked
So, here’s what I did:
-
I began using my interactions with the team which show up on some days. I would select chat with team or chat with coach.
-
I continued to perform well, I was leading the league in most hitting stats. I was even getting the occasional on the field conversation with the manager.
-
Finally, after a few in-game weeks, during one of those between-game cutscenes, my agent called me up. He said the GM had been asking about me and the agent feels I am not happy.
-
He asked if I wanted to be traded! Finally. I obviously said “Yes!” and it started a cutscene where my agent had a conversation with me.
-
He let me choose my new team, I chose the Giants.
And boom, just like that, I was traded. It took a little longer than I expected, but the key was to be patient, keep playing, engage in the story elements, and wait for the opportunity to present itself. Don’t just sit there mashing buttons; actually play the career mode as it’s intended!
Hope this helps some of you out there. Good luck getting traded to your dream team!